Toby Keith Wrote a Song for His Dead Friend. At the Funeral, It Was the One Song He Couldn’t Sing.
Some songs begin as memories. Others begin as grief. “Cryin’ for Me (Wayman’s Song)” came from both.
Toby Keith wrote it for Wayman Tisdale, the former NBA star turned jazz bassist who was also one of Toby Keith’s close friends. Wayman Tisdale was known for his bright smile, his easy warmth, and the kind of talent that seemed to spill into every room he entered. When Wayman Tisdale died on May 15, 2009, after a long battle with cancer, the loss hit hard.
Toby Keith did what many songwriters do when words fail: he turned to music. But this was not a song built around pity. It was not about asking people to feel sorry for Wayman Tisdale. It was about what remains behind when someone dear is gone. The empty seat. The quiet. The strange, heavy silence that follows a life full of laughter.
A Song Written in the Shadow of Goodbye
“Cryin’ for Me (Wayman’s Song)” carried a tenderness that felt personal because it was personal. Toby Keith was not writing from the outside. He was writing as a friend who had watched Wayman Tisdale fight through illness and still keep his spirit visible to others. The song became Toby Keith’s way of saying that the pain did not end with the funeral. It stayed with the people left standing.
Then came the moment Toby Keith had intended to face: the funeral itself. He planned to sing the song there, as a final tribute to his friend. But grief does not always obey a plan. When the time arrived, Toby Keith could not get through it. The song was too close, too raw, too full of everything he had not yet learned how to say aloud.
The Song He Couldn’t Finish
Instead of “Cryin’ for Me (Wayman’s Song)”, Toby Keith sang Willie Nelson’s “Angel Flying Too Close to the Ground”. That choice says as much as any speech could. In a moment when Toby Keith needed to honor Wayman Tisdale, he reached for a song that could carry the emotion without forcing him to push through the wound.
It was not weakness. It was love, showing up in its most human form.
Months later, Toby Keith finally shared “Cryin’ for Me (Wayman’s Song)” with the public. The song reached No. 6 on the country chart, but the chart position was never the heart of the story. The real meaning was in the reason it existed at all.
Toby Keith wrote the song to say goodbye to one man. At the moment that goodbye mattered most, he could not sing it. And somehow, that made the tribute even more honest.
